Best practice to not be subject for 212(e)

Best practice to not be subject to 212(e) for a J-1 visa holder

Some J-1 exchange visitors must go back to their home country for at least 2 years before they can change to certain other visa types or become a US permanent resident.

This can be a barrier for some exchange students who would like to continue their studies after the exchange program or scholars who would like to extend their stay.

Therefore, this post will break down everything about 212 (e) based on the USCIS Policy Manual.

212(e) indication on the J-1 visa

Contents

  1. Who is subject to 212(e)?
  2. Common myths about 212(e)
  3. Best Practices to not be subject to 212(e)
  4. How to apply for a 212(e) waiver?
  5. How can you demonstrate that you meet the 212 (e)?

Who is subject to 212(e)?

According to the J exchange program, Form DS-2019 will mark 212(e) if:

  • The exchange visitor’s category is Alien Physician (PL 94-484) or
  • The exchange visitor’s program was financed by:
    o A U.S. Government Agency
    o The Exchange Visitor’s Government
    o Current Program Sponsor (for G-1, G-2, and G-3 programs only)

Note that the SEVIS system does not add 212(e) indication based on the Exchange Visitor Skills List but the Consular Officer might make a decision based on the skills list.

This means that if the J-1 visa holder is subject to 212(e) due to the Exchange Visitor Skills List, it’s not because of the ARO who issued Form DS-2019- it is the consular officer’s decision.

Consular Officer’s decision on Form DS-2019

Exceptions to the requirement are going to be when there is…

  • War or civil unrest in the home country
  • Travel bans imposed by the home country
  • Shifting borders or political changes

It is worth noting that USCIS considers exceptions on a case-by-case basis.


Common myths about 212(e)

  1. J-1 visa holders get subjected to 212(e) due to the major.
    • NO! On March 11, 2024, the exchange program confirmed that the SEVIS system does not mark 212(e) based on the Exchange Visitor Skills list.
  2. 212(e) mark can be removed from DS-2019 when correct funding documents are submitted
    • NO! Once Form DS-2019 is generated, the 212(e) indication cannot be removed. If the funding information is entered incorrectly, (A)ROs (school officials) will have to cancel the record and re-issue the new Form DS-2019
  3. 212(e) indication on Form DS-2019 supersedes the one in the visa
    • NO! 212(e) note on Form DS-2019 tells the consular officer that the J-1 applicant may be subject to 212(e) regulation. Ultimately, it will be at the Consular Officer’s discretion to decide whether the J-1 visa applicant is going to be subject to 212(e) or not.

The visa annotation supersedes the indicator on the Form. For example, if the Form is marked subject to 212(e) but the visa annotation says that the bearer is not subject, the exchange visitor will not be subject to the 212(e) requirement.

SEVIS Quick Tip: Application and Request Timeouts and updated 212e Guidance

Best Practices to not be subject to 212(e)

  1. Go for the category that is not subject to 212(e)! According to the J SEVIS program, “exchange visitors participating in the Au Pair and Summer Work Travel exchange visitor program categories are not subject to INA 212(e).”
  2. Self-fund or receive funding/grants from non-government entities
  3. If you are issued Form DS-2019 as an Alien Physician or for a graduate medical training program, you may consider providing your service in an underserved area for three years (Conrad State 30 Program). Continue to read the post to learn more about the 212(e) waiver eligibility and process.

How to apply for a 212(e) waiver?

If you’re on a J-1 visa, you usually have to go back to your home country for 2 years before you can apply for certain visas or change your immigration status in the US. However, there are a few ways to get around this using what’s called a “waiver“.

Eligibility to apply for a waiver

  • Hardship: Leaving the US would cause extreme hardship for your spouse or child who are US citizens or permanent residents.
  • Persecution: You might be harmed or mistreated because of your religion, race, or political beliefs if you go back to your home country.
  • “No Objection” Letter: Your home country’s government says it’s okay that you don’t return.
    • It can take a long time to get a “no objection” waiver recommendation from the Department of State
    • Once the “no objection” recommendation is received, USCIS usually makes a decision on the I-612 waiver form within two weeks.
  • Working for the US Government: A US government agency needs you to stay in the US for work that benefits the public.
  • Medical Doctor in Underserved Area: You agree to work as a doctor in a place that doesn’t have enough doctors for at least 3 years.
    • If a J-1 doctor gets a waiver to work in a medically underserved area, their J-2 spouse cannot change their status to H-1B until the doctor completes their 3-year work commitment.
    • Once the commitment is fulfilled, the doctor and their J-2 family members can then apply to change their status or become permanent residents.
    • If the doctor doesn’t fulfill the commitment, everyone is subject to the 2-year foreign residence requirement again.

To learn more about the waiver, check out the official Travel.state.gov website!

Important things to note about the waiver

It is important to remember that J-1 visa holders who meet the waiver eligibility must go through the waiver process as the waiver is not applied automatically.

As you can see above, some waiver criteria involve the government’s action which can make the process complicated. If you can, it is advisable to get help from an immigration lawyer.

Lastly, even if you applied for a waiver, all J-1 visa holders must maintain their J-1 status until a decision is made.


How can you demonstrate that you meet the 212 (e)?

USCIS will assess if an exchange visitor has met the 2-year foreign residence requirement using the “preponderance of the evidence” standard in subsequent applications/petitions.

J-1 applicants can submit evidence like:

  • A chart of days spent in the home country
    • If an exchange visitor spends even part of a day in their home country or country of the last residence during travel, that day will count towards the 2-year requirement.
  • Passport stamps
  • Employment records

USCIS will consider cases where it’s practically impossible for an exchange visitor to fulfill the 2-year requirement on a case-by-case basis. They’ll consult with the Department of State in these situations.

To sum up, the foreign residence requirement applies to certain J-1 exchange visitors who must reside in their home country for a total of 2 years before applying for specific visas or changing their status.

The best way to not be subject to 212 (e) is to avoid factors that contribute toward being subject to 212(e) like government funding.

To learn more about the important J-1 visa rules, check out the J-1 visa page.

Be Savvies

Related Posts

J-1 exchange students? Apply for Academic Training for internships
J-1 签证

作为 J-1 交换生赴美实习?学术培训了解一下

交换生是指短期来美国学习和体验不同文化的学生。与获得学位(例如学士学位、硕士学位或博士学位)的攻读学位的学生不同,交换生不会从美国院校获得学位,而是从其本国大学获得学位。在签证方面,攻读学位的学生通常获得F-1学生签证,而非攻读学位(交换)的学生则获得J-1学生签证。但交换生有可能获得 F-1 签证。我为什么要谈论签证?这是因为 F-1 和 J-1 签证持有者都必须知道,根据移民法规,未经授权,他们不得在校外工作。因此,为了在校外公司实习,您应该根据您的签证类型申请不同的就业授权计划。例如,F-1学生应申请并获得批准用于在校期间实习的CPT和毕业后在校外工作的Post-completion OPT。对于 J-1 学生,有一个名为学术培训的项目,通过学术培训项目,交换生可以在校外工作。然而,学术培训规则不如 F-1 学生项目明确,因此大多数 J-1 交换生不会利用该项目。因此,如果您想充分利用在美国的留学经历,请仔细阅读本文,看看您是否符合资格。通过阅读本文,您将能够了解以下内容: (1) Purpose. The primary purpose of academic training is to permit a student, other than a student intern described in paragraph (i) of this section, to participate in an academic training program during his or her studies, without

Read More »